Across the country, small and mid-sized businesses are receiving formal legal demand letters alleging that standard marketing pixels—like Google Analytics, Meta Pixels, and session-replay software—violate 1960s state wiretapping statutes.
To help business owners cut through the noise, separate myth from reality, and protect their digital infrastructure without destroying their marketing data, KWSM sat down with Karen Batcher, President and Founder of Alliance Data Privacy Solutions.
Karen is an experienced privacy law attorney specializing in California privacy laws (CCPA/CPRA) and European Union regulations (GDPR). Her practice focuses on evaluating digital privacy programs, identifying compliance gaps, reviewing policies and data contracts, and guiding companies through complex state and federal privacy frameworks.
Below is an executive summary of our in-depth Q&A with Karen on the state of website privacy compliance.
Want to read the unedited interview? [Click here to read Karen Batcher’s Full Privacy Q&A].
1. Why 1960s Wiretapping Laws Target Modern Websites
The recent surge in demand letters isn’t caused by a new privacy law. Instead, plaintiff attorneys and automated scanning bots are applying California’s 1967 wiretapping statute (CIPA) to modern website code. They argue that when a third-party tracking pixel loads in a user’s browser, that third party is illegally “intercepting” electronic communications or acting as an unauthorized “pen register”. Coupled with statutory damages of $5,000 per violation, serial plaintiffs have created an industrialized demand-letter environment.
2. Geography and Business Size Do Not Protect You
A common misconception among business owners is that small B2B companies or businesses outside California are immune. In reality, automated bots systematically scan websites nationwide regardless of company size or location. Karen’s latest clients to receive CIPA demand letters include a local surfboard manufacturer, a surf retail shop, and a small machine shop. Furthermore, a business can fall below CCPA/CPRA statutory revenue thresholds and still face a CIPA wiretapping claim.
3. The Difference Between a Cookie Banner and Technical Compliance
A basic pop-up banner that tells visitors “We use cookies” offers little protection if tracking scripts fire unrestricted in the background before a user chooses or after they opt out. Under California law, consent cannot apply retroactively to data that was already transmitted upon page load. While U.S. law is primarily an Opt-Out framework (notice + choice + honoring browser opt-out signals like Global Privacy Control), your website’s actual network behavior must strictly correspond to the visitor’s choice.
4. The Biggest Exposure: Privacy Policy Mismatches
From a litigation perspective, the most dangerous vulnerability is a mismatch between what your privacy policy says and what your website code actually transmits. Standard, generic privacy templates often fail to name third-party ad platforms or claim “we do not sell data” while running retargeting pixels (which California legally defines as “sharing”). Privacy policies must be drafted from a technical data-flow inventory, not copy-pasted from a template.
5. What to Do If You Receive a Demand Letter
If your business receives a privacy demand letter:
- Do Not Panic, But Do Not Ignore It: A demand letter is an allegation, not a court judgment, but it triggers a legal duty to preserve evidence under California law.
- Preserve First, Then Remediate: Document your historical website configurations, tag manager containers, and server logs before making changes. Once documented, promptly correct any technical pixel issues to prevent further exposure.
- Do Not Contact the Claimant Directly: Consult legal counsel and check your cyber or E&O insurance policies before responding or negotiating.
6. How to Protect Your Site Without Hurting Marketing Data
Businesses do not need to shut down their marketing analytics to stay compliant. The key is conducting a network-level tracking audit to classify every tag, script, and SDK operating on your site. By combining an accurate privacy policy with a modern Consent Management Platform (CMP) configured under an Opt-Out framework, you can honor user privacy choices while preserving valuable first-party marketing data.
Is Your Website Prepared?
The gap between what your privacy policy promises and what your website code actually transmits is where legal exposure begins.
- Read the Full Legal Analysis: Explore Karen Batcher’s complete, detailed answers in our [Full Website Privacy Q&A].
- Get Technical Fixes: Read Web Director Stephen Wagner’s guide on [Implementing a 3-Part Opt-Out CMP Architecture].
- Audit Your Site: Contact KWSM today to schedule a technical website tracking audit and safeguard your digital infrastructure
Important Update:
On September 30, 2026, California signed Senate Bill 690 into law, amending the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) to eliminate the private right of action for website tracking violations under Section 638.51, and making this protection retroactive for the past two years.
While this significantly reduces the risk of private lawsuits over standard web technologies, businesses must still maintain robust privacy policies as plaintiffs’ attorneys are expected to pivot to other liability theories and wiretapping statutes.